First time here?

The Latest Radio Broadcast

The Latest KarmaCritique

  • stuck.jpg
    stuck.jpg
    Year Released:
    2007

    STUCK (2007) Story and Directed by Stuart Gordon.

    Opening titles say “Inspired by a true story.”

    Average: 10 (1 vote)

The Latest Comments

EDITING TRICKS #1

sonnyboo's picture

This is another HORRORS OF WAR web doc, this one an INDIE FILM TIP looking at some of the most rudimentary editing tricks and concepts.

CUTTING ON MOTION is one of the most effective, but traditional editing techniques. There are other ideas and more modern editing tosses these "rules" out the window, but they can be effective when used. I hope you like this video.

 

My role(s) in this film:
Director
Writer
Producer
Editor
Actor
FX
Other
No votes yet
FableForge's picture

WOW. Kinda like.. watching how a magic trick is done

 You know, I think I'll never be able to see movies the same way again. I think it was subconcious... "cut in motion" makes it feel like the edit wasnt even there, you just dont notice it, which I guess is the whole point. On the other hand, one thing I learned watching thousands (not an exaggeration) of films in OTL, is that a tell tale mark of someone who is newbie, is the strange pauses and timing of the dialogue on screen. John doe will say a sentence, then there is a second of pause while we see Jane Doe's face, doing nothing, and then her cue comes up and she says her line. Then we see John Doe's face, cue comes up, he says his line. It feels like they're talking turns to talk, which kill the realism completely. If the editing had been tighter it may have flown smoother, is what I always thought, but now I see the science behind that hunch: cut in motion. 

Very nice. I guess its things like this that make editing an art, in addition to a science. Very good video.  

sonnyboo's picture

Cutting on motion was

Cutting on motion was really fine tuned in by D.W.Griffith during the early years of cinema with Birth of a Nation etc.  You can see it in most movies out there. It's (one) effective editing technique.

 

There are more modernized, less traditional editing styles today that use jumpcuts and very jarring editorial styles. These came more from the French New Wave era of the 1960's and have been adopted in mainstream movies today by people like Oliver Stone, Steven Soderberg, and Darren Arronofsky. Even then, their use of things like jumpcuts or breaking continuity is always motivated.  If there is a REASON for the cut, it cannot be wrong. If you make cuts or do things just because... then it's wasted and not really supporting the story you're trying to tell. That is if you're trying to tell a story.  

Sunlight_Digital's picture

next dimension of cutting on motion

Besides the obvious cut from one camera angle to the next on the same subject, sometimes a sense of fluidity is maintained by using the motion of one scene to compliment the next.

Often symbolism can be used in the same way as a means to bridge a concept or mood layered into the story ...

for example, like...  smoke rising from a stereotypical film noir detective's cigarette dissolving into a foggy mysterious scene while his VO narration continues on with his story about deciding to fly from his New York office to London to take on the pretty British girl's case... etc.

- AK

sonnyboo's picture

YES, true

Sunlight_Digital wrote:

Besides the obvious cut from one camera angle to the next on the same subject, sometimes a sense of fluidity is maintained by using the motion of one scene to compliment the next.

 

One of the coolest examples of this was in the jet Li movie
DANNY THE DOG (released in the U.S. as "UNLEASHED") where sand was
pouring out of a punching bag and it dissolved into rain hitting the
top of a car.

I agree, much like something as simple as a dolly move at the end of one scene continues into the beginning of the next scene. Those are more TRANSITIONAL edits from one scene to another, and less within a scene and cuts you would make more often. It's a great point though and the idea for another video....

 

You are right also that this is rudimentary, but it's staggering how many  filmmakers don't know or don't use even the most basic concepts of filmmaking. Even the effect concepts.

 

Post new comment

Security question, designed to stop automated spam bots
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

User login

Who's Online

There are currently 0 users and 60 guests online.

The Latest Donations

John Meredith25Sep 30 2007
sonnyboo15Sep 30 2007
dmaymay100Aug 28 2007
victorpeceno50Jul 11 2007
curare995Jul 7 2007

The Latest Poll

Best Actor Of All Time In The Gangster/Crime Film Genre
Al Pacino: The Godfather Trilogy/Scarface/Carlito's Way/Donnie Brasco/Serpico
29%
Ray Liota: Goodfellas/Cop Land
14%
Robert De Niro: Goodfellas/The Godfather Part 2/Mean Streets
29%
James Cagney: White Heat/Angels With Dirty Faces/The Public Enemy
14%
Marlon Brando: The Godfather Trilogy
0%
Joe Pesci: Goodfellas/Casino/A Bronx Tale
14%
Total votes: 7